AI rip-offs targeting sapphic books

The sapphic book community has been facing a lot of challenges this year, from the growing fear of LGBTQ+ book bans and censorship to a noticeable drop in sales for many authors.

Now we are faced with a new threat, and I wanted to share it with readers because you are a vital part of the community, and authors are going to need your help and support to weather this latest round of nonsense.

 

TL;DR (Too Long; Didn’t Read): AI rip-offs are flooding the sapphic book market

If you don’t have time to read the entire blog post, here’s the short version, but I do encourage you to come back and read it all!

The sapphic fiction community is under attack by scammers using AI to churn out rip-off books based on real sapphic novels.

129 suspicious titles were identified, mostly published within the past month, likely all by the same person under 17 different pseudonyms.

This blog post shares a list of red flags to help identify possible AI rip-offs.

Things readers can do:

• Spread awareness about AI rip-offs by sharing this blog post.
• If you come across a suspected rip-off, alert the original author so they can check it out.
• Be very careful not to jump to conclusions and accuse potential real authors. Some similarities might be coincidental or due to both books being based on the same tropes.
• Use Amazon’s “report an issue” feature or leave 1-star reviews only if you’re absolutely certain it’s a rip-off—preferably after getting confirmation from the original author.

 

The longer version of what happened

Last week, a reader alerted one of my fellow authors to a sapphic book that felt suspiciously similar to the author’s. Then another author found another one.

After spending years tracking down stolen translations within the sapphic fiction community, I have developed a good eye for finding illegitimate books, so I went down a rabbit hole and combed through all sapphic new releases of the last month.

What I found was shocking: This isn’t a case of a single person using another’s book as a template to write their own. What I found is a disturbing pattern of AI-generated books based on real authors’ works, and I fear it will only get worse if we don’t stop it now.

 

What I found so far

• 129 sapphic books that I very strongly believe have been ripped off from other authors using AI. That’s not even counting the translations based on these rip-offs!
• For 26 of those books, I could identify the originals and alerted the authors.
• Those 129 books were published by 17 different “authors” (I use that word very lightly because those people aren’t actually authors; they are scammers out to make a quick buck by profiting off other people’s work). There are strong indications that those 17 “authors” are all the same person or, at most, a couple of different people, as they all follow the same pattern (see “red flags” below).

 

What’s the big deal?

You might be thinking: If this doesn’t meet the legal definition of plagiarism (see below for an explanation of why it likely doesn’t), then what’s the big deal?

Frankly, as an author who spends hundreds of hours creating complex characters, coming up with story ideas, and creating realistic plots, I don’t much care about the legal definition. To me and to all other authors I talked to, this is theft.

These people are not writers. They use AI to scrape our plots, our blurbs, and our characters to make money without putting in any of the work. They steal from real books written by queer women, nonbinary writers, and other marginalized creators, likely without having any idea of what it means to be part of the LGBTQ+ community.

If they published 130 rip-offs within just the last month, can you imagine what it will do to the sapphic book community long-term? They will flood the market with mass-produced AI rip-offs, making it harder for readers to find authentic books and threatening authors’ livelihoods.

These books also erode readers’ trust in authors. Readers might start to hesitate to take a chance on a new or new-to-them author, fearing that any author they aren’t familiar with might be one of the AI-spamming culprits.

For some authors, this might be the straw that breaks the camel’s back and makes them give up writing—because what’s the point if anyone can just steal their ideas, toss them into AI, and make money off it?

That’s why I’m speaking up and taking the time to write this blog post. I know it’s a long one, but it’s important, so please bear with me and read all the way to the end.

 

Red flags: How to spot AI rip-offs of sapphic books

Below, I’ve listed some warning signs to watch out for.

Important: None of these signs alone can confirm anything, so please read the caveats below carefully. But when a book displays several of these red flags, it becomes more and more likely that you’re dealing with an AI rip-off. Please make sure you read this blog post all the way to the end because the last thing we want is to accuse innocent authors.

Here’s the list of common red flags:

• They use generative AI for everything: They create new covers using AI, rewrite the original blurb using AI, and use AI to rewrite the book.

• Obvious similarities, but with changes: The books are not exact copies of the originals, but the similarities are obvious. They change the character names and often other details, e.g., a soccer player in the original becomes a cricket player in the rip-off. The plot isn’t 100% identical, but the parallels are still very obvious. For example, in the original (Sometimes We Fly by Cheyenne Blue), the newsreader main character is dragged out of a work dinner to the police station because her 16-year-old daughter has been arrested for carjacking. In the AI rip-off, the newsreader main character is dragged out of reading the news to the police station because her 16-year-old daughter has been arrested for vandalizing.
• Caveat: Not every book with a similar idea is a rip-off. Romance novels often use the same character types, e.g., ice queen CEOs, and the same tropes, which naturally leads to books having similar key scenes. For example, fake relationship romances usually have a scene in which the characters have to kiss to convince others they are a couple. Plenty of them also have an only-one-bed scene. That’s not necessarily plagiarism or a sign of a rip-off. Look for patterns of similarities that can’t be explained by mere coincidence or the authors using the same tropes. In the example above, what are the chances of two sapphic books being published in the same month with a main character who is a newsreader with a 16-year-old daughter who’s arrested so she’s dragged to the police station at the beginning of the book? Those are very specific parallels that can’t be explained by both books using the same trope.
• More similarities at the beginning of the book: What they seem to be doing is to feed the original blurb (book description) into AI and ask it to write the book. That means the first 25-50% of the book will have more similarities to the original since that’s the part of the book the blurbs covers. The second half of the book will often deviate considerably and might go into an entirely different direction. The plot might become confusing, with entire plotlines going nowhere or becoming tangled, or the book might have an ending that is strangely anticlimactic.
• Caveat: A confusing plot, dropped plotlines, or an unsatisfying ending aren’t sure signs that a book is an AI rip-off. It could be just bad writing. It’s easy to tell a well-written book apart from an AI-generated book, but harder to differentiate an AI-generated book from a book that just isn’t written well.
• The blurbs echo the original: The blurb has very obvious similarities to the original, often using some of the same phrases, but rephrasing other parts.
• Example:
• In the example below, I put the instances where the rip-off and the original used the exact same words or phrases in ALL CAPS:
• Original (The Princess Match by Clare Lydon):
• Princess Victoria has perfected the ROYAL PLAYBOOK: calculated SMILE, CONVENIENT boyfriend, impeccable press. But behind the tiara ticks a heart that’s tired of playing by the rules.
• Enter Ashleigh Woods: England’s football CAPTAIN, media darling, and living proof that AUTHENTICITY scores every time. When Victoria PINS AN MBE ON Ash’s lapel, the INSTANT chemistry jolts both their worlds.
• STOLEN GLANCES become SECRET meetings. Private texts become tabloid gold. And suddenly, Victoria’s tearing up her royal rulebook for a woman who makes her feel like more than her title. Ash has faced down penalty shootouts in European Cup finals, but winning Victoria’s heart? That’s the MATCH OF HER LIFE.
• When their romance hits the headlines, it’s game on: bow to tradition, or fight for a love that could change history. Victoria’s got a crown to inherit. Ash has a legacy to defend. Neither planned to start a revolution, but when destiny meets desire, sometimes you have to risk it all to win.
• Rip-off:
• Princess Evelyn lives by the ROYAL PLAYBOOK: duty first, SMILE always, maintain the perfect image. Trapped by tradition and stifled by a CONVENIENT, passionless relationship with Lord Arthur, she secretly yearns for something real, something more.
• Freya Brown: England’s charismatic cricket CAPTAIN, a powerhouse on the pitch and refreshingly AUTHENTIC off it. When Evelyn PINS AN MBE ON Freya’s blazer, the connection is instant, electric, and utterly forbidden.
• STOLEN GLANCES ignite SECRET texts. Witty banter deepens into late-night confessions. Clandestine meetings in borrowed flats and hidden corners explode into passionate encounters that leave them both breathless and wanting more. Evelyn finds herself shedding her royal skin, discovering a fierce desire she never knew she possessed, while Freya navigates the thrilling, terrifying reality of falling for a woman destined for a throne.
• Their sweet, funny, and intensely sexy affair is a refuge – until the paparazzi lens shatters their secret world. Splashed across the headlines, their love becomes a national scandal. Evelyn faces an impossible choice: uphold centuries of tradition and marry the ‘suitable’ man, or fight for the cricket captain who holds her heart. Freya, accustomed to pressure on the field, now faces the MATCH OF HER LIFE – battling prejudice, protocol, and the palace itself for a future with the woman she loves.
• Duty demands sacrifice. Her heart demands Freya. In a world bound by rules, can Princess Evelyn make her play and choose a love that could rewrite history, or will the weight of the Crown crush their forbidden romance forever?
• AI-generated covers, often with issues: As I mentioned, the covers are almost all AI-generated. Many of the covers don’t have the correct author names but either no author name at all, the wrong name, or some AI-created gobbledygook. Some covers do have the correct author name, though.





• Caveat: Not all AI-generated covers are necessarily rip-offs. But not a single author I know would publish a book with a cover that doesn’t have their name on it. It’s against Amazon’s terms of service too, so authors know to avoid that.
• Ebooks only: The books are only available as ebooks, not as paperbacks. Some are in KU; some aren’t.
• Caveat: While most authors make their books available as paperbacks, there might be some legitimate authors who publish digital only, so that alone is not a red flag.
• Impossible publishing speed: They publish their books faster than any human author not using AI could, often publishing multiple books within the same week.
• No author presence: These scammers have no social media presence. Their author profile on Amazon is usually blank, without a photo or author’s bio.
• Caveat: Not every author who prefers not to use a photo or doesn’t have an author’s bio on Amazon is creating AI rip-offs. They might simply prefer to stay anonymous.
• Publishing across different target audiences: They often (but not always) also publish M/M and M/F romances, not just sapphic books.
• Caveat: There are hard-working authors who publish in multiple categories, across sexual identities. That alone isn’t a red flag.
• Instant AI translations: Many also have translations into multiple languages, mostly French and German. Those translations are AI-generated too, so the quality is bad, at times with pronouns being confused (using “he” instead of “she” in a few places because the AI apparently expects that a love story between two people will be between a man and a woman…).



• Caveat: It goes without saying that not every author whose books were translated into multiple languages is using AI or creating AI rip-offs. Most of my own books are available in German because I translate them myself, and several of my books have also been translated into French by a French publisher. However, the AI translations are often published within a few days of each other, and very few authors paying translators and editors could afford that.
• Superficial diversity: I hate to say it, but the covers are often more diverse than the average sapphic book, often depicting an interracial couple. Not all of the rip-offs have a person of color on the cover, but it’s more common than you would see it in the top 100, for example. The diversity is only superficial, though, as the book isn’t written authentically from a person of color’s perspective.
• Caveat: It should go without saying that, of course, not every book that has an interracial couple on the cover is an AI rip-off.
• Targeting (mostly) bestsellers: Most often but not always, they steal books that are currently in the lesbian romance/lesbian fiction top 100 on Amazon.
• Repeating names: They often (but not always) repeat the same character names across books: Seraphina, Rossi, Maya, Sterling, Rowan, Thorne, Vance, Moreau. Certain place names are common too, e.g., Willow Creek.
• Caveat: Just because an author uses any of those names doesn’t mean their book is an AI rip-off. For example, Chris Zett’s characters in Flipping Hearts and Homes are named Rowan and Maia, yet I know for a fact that she spent months coming up with just the right names for her characters.

 

The suspected “authors” who very likely create AI rip-offs

Here’s a list of “author” names I very strongly suspect of creating AI rip-offs. I’ll keep this list updated and add more names to it whenever I find more scammers, so you might want to check back every now and then.

For the first 12 names on the list, I could identify one or several originals. For the last 5 names, I couldn’t identify the originals, yet I’m confident that these “authors” are creating rip-offs because they show the exact same pattern described above, including using names like “Seraphina.”

Some of them even use their own author names—or those of authors also on the list—for their characters. There’s a very clear connection between all of those authors, and I strongly suspect they are all the same person or at most a couple of different people operating after the same pattern.

• Judith Tucker (has already been removed from Amazon)
• Charlie Myers
• Hailey Potter
• Rachel Riley
• Nicole Carr
• Valerie Smith
• Queen Xavier
• Elena Jacob
• Sophia Cooper
• Sage Hardy
• Sandra Benson
• Elara Skye
• Juliet Walker
• Denise S. Willard
• Maya Ramos
• Abigail Bennett
• Julie Hills

 

What has been done so far?

Several authors and I have reached out to Amazon, but we haven’t heard back yet.

The first handful of books we discovered are no longer available on Amazon, but we’re not sure whether Amazon removed them or the culprit took them down because they were garnering too many 1-star reviews.

We don’t yet know Amazon’s stance on those AI rip-offs. Since those people aren’t copying our stories word-by-word and the AI introduced enough differences to the original, it likely doesn’t count as plagiarism. Ideas aren’t protected by copyright, only the specific way an author wrote that idea is. The law hasn’t caught up with what AI technology can do, so authors likely don’t have much legal protection in these cases.

 

What can you, as a reader, do to help?

• Spread the word. Share this blog post with fellow readers. The more people are aware of the existence of these rip-offs and how to identify them, the better our chance to stop this.
• Don’t buy or read rip-offs. Learn how to recognize red flags so you’re not supporting those fake “authors” by buying their books or reading them in KU. The goal is to prevent them from making any money. That’s probably the only thing that will discourage them from continuing their scams.
• Keep an eye out for rip-offs: While you’re reading, pay attention to books that sound eerily similar to other sapphic books you have read. Readers are often how authors find out about rip-offs and plagiarism since many of you read may more than the average author, so we rely on eagle-eyed readers to alert us of potential problems.
• Don’t avoid new-to-you authors. We don’t want to create a climate where every author is under suspicion. That could be extremely harmful to authors, especially debut authors who haven’t had a chance yet to establish a relationship with readers.
• Don’t jump to conclusions. It’s important to be extremely careful when making any claims about plagiarism or AI-generated rip-offs. Accusing an author of copying another’s work can have serious consequences for that person’s career and mental health. The last thing we want is to harm any innocent authors. That’s why I included all of these caveats. Please be careful not to go around accusing authors of publishing AI rip-offs or plagiarism because they might fit a couple of the criteria listed above.
• Alert the author. If you discover a book that you suspect might be a rip-off, contact the original author. They might be better equipped to tell whether it’s indeed a rip-off or a just coincidental similarity.
• Report rip-offs, but only if you’re sure. You could report rip-offs to Amazon if you are absolutely, positively certain it’s a rip-off. There’s a “report an issue” link on each book’s Amazon page. But be very careful not to accidentally report the original or a book that just has accidental similarities. When in doubt, don’t report the books yourself but alert the original author.
• Review rip-offs. Leave a 1-star review and warn fellow readers that it’s an AI-generated rip-off. You could mention the title and author of the original book to guide fellow readers to the original. Again, only do that if you are 100% certain or once the original author has confirmed it’s a rip-off.
• Help authors whose books have been ripped-off. Some authors will reach out to their readers for help via their newsletter or their Facebook reader groups, letting you know their book has been ripped off. That’s when you can help by leaving a 1-star review or reporting the rip-off as described above.
• Check out the “authors” listed above. Do any of their books sound familiar? There are still plenty of books I haven’t been able to identify. If you are sure you recognize which original book the rip-off is based on, let me know—I can tell you if I already discovered the same book and reached out to the original author or not.
• Support the originals. Support real authors by reading their books and leaving honest reviews.

 

This situation is heartbreaking and infuriating, not just for the authors whose hard work is being stolen, but for readers who deserve authentic, thoughtfully crafted stories instead of regurgitated AI slop without any soul or sense.

I hope we can all work together to spread awareness, stop this exploitation of our community, and support real authors.

Thanks for reading,

Jae